Therapists first off, vary quite a lot, and what they do can vary quite a lot. But here is what some of my sessions have looked like.
Pre College: I was 11 and my parents were constantly fighting and my grandmother had just died. I talked to a therapist about how sad my Grandmother's death was making me. She literally fell asleep.
Takeaway: If your therapist isn't listening to you, dump them. This goes double if they sleep.
College: I had six sessions, and either nothing was discussed, or I bawled about the same idiot who I talked about in my last post. He had just dumped me for the 1st (out of 3? 4? Times? I lost count). time.
Takeaway: If you don't feel like you're getting anything out of a session, you probably aren't. Drop them and go somewhere else. Give it 3-6 times then get out of there.
Post College: I had my first "real" therapy, where I was going because I felt like something was wrong with me (spoiler, there was, I had very severe depression) instead of because someone told me to. She was really sweet. She listened as I ranted and cried about THE SAME BOY. She never made me feel stupid. She asked if I just wanted to talk or if I wanted an official diagnosis. I said I just wanted to talk. She never made me feel pressured.
Takeaway: Your therapist should always listen to what you want and need. They should adapt their style to what works for you. They should ask questions and let you do the talking. They should interject occasionally with a tool -- this therapist talk me the 5,4,3,2,1 technique.
AFTER THE BREAK (After we moved and I became suicidal).
There were more therapists that I am probably remembering here, and I am omitting at least 1 here, by virtue of only seeing her once.
The one with the puppets.
Easily one of the best therapists I've ever had, her methods were unconventional. She worked with little puppets, brought her dog once, and had water in her room. She listened well, brought up issues that mattered, and seemed to see beneath the surface. She was also the only person I've ever met that could talk me down from a ledge. I used to call her Mary Poppins, because she was honestly magical. She used a combination of conventional wisdom -- she insisted I needed meds -- and unconventional wisdom, like her puppets. Why did I stop going? She was incredibly expensive!! And didn't take insurance!
Takeaway: Even if someone is unconventional doesn't mean they're not right. Techniques that were super weird that worked. Puppets: She used it to explain why and how my suicidal thoughts were arising, including the idea that they were tied to my self esteem (they were) and a defense mechanism (they are). She also talk me to picture the suicidal thoughts on a dimmer switch. I used it a few times, and it actually worked better than you'd think. The mind is a powerful thing. Don't disregard weird techniques if they work for you.
The one with the candle
Highly recommended, I found this woman lacking. It just wasn't a good chemistry. Her technique seemed basic to me -- she did not do anything that the other therapists didn't, but came across as much more wary and judgmental. I was always concerned to tell her when I had suicidal thoughts and she was appalled when she learned that I had more than one therapist (I was trying to work with someone more than once a week and no one did. I was also interested in having different opinions and finding the perfect match.) The last thing she did was after every session was make me make a wish. Yeah. Corny.
Takeaway: If you are afraid to confide in your therapist, that's a big red flag. If you feel like they're judging you, or they clearly are, that's another red flag. In the end I made my excuses -- and left. One major point though, to be fair, she is correct, most therapists will not be cool with you cheating on them. However, she failed to realize that I was struggling so badly I needed to see two therapists at that time. I could not get through the week otherwise. She failed to see the severity of the situation or to adapt to it. She tried (offered to text me any time, which was very generous and I would love that now) but it wasn't enough at the time. Not a huge diss on her, but in the end it wasn't a good match.
The one who hated Grass Valley.
This woman was clearly out of her comfort zone when she met me (she instantly knew I needed meds, and bless her for that). She was clearly used to clients who she could help heal organically through things like meditation and running. But she knew I was different. She was very adamant about what I needed to do and she was wonderful at talking with my parents. But she did not have many tools. She let me talk quite a lot, told me I needed to get the hell out of the area, as it was stiffing for someone my age (not wrong, but not helpful either), but her main issue was she would lose focus mid session and start looking at her phone if it rang or just space out. I think she may have been going through a hard time of her own, but in the end, considering how far I was driving, it just wasn't working out.
Takeaway: You want a therapist who listens, so if they look at their phone at all, that's a huge flag. You also want a therapist who lets you talk, but you also want one who helps you -- without being phony or controlling -- looks at the positive. It should be a balance, and they should always help you leave in a better place than when you come in. If they're harping on something you can't change, that's a big no-no.
The man
This was an example of where it just wasn't a good fit. I'm sure for other clients he was golden, but for me, every therapy session felt more like a gossip session. He'd gleefully rub his hands and sit back and listen. He gave me a few handouts, and he was the best therapist to get a hold of in a crisis, other than the puppet lady, but for me, it just wasn't a good match. It felt, again, like the severity of the situation wasn't understood. There was no forward moment. I was relieved when he moved his office further than I wanted to drive.
Takeaway: If you don't end every therapy appointment feeling like you've moved forward in some way, that is not a good therapy session. Once you've left an appointment, you should feel (a) uplifted (b) calm or relieved (c) thoughtful (d) worn out from dealing with your issues.
If you leave it feeling like you're wasting your time, you probably are.
The trainee
She was very into one technique, and one technique only. She believed that all things stemmed from . . . I can't believe I don't remember this. I think it was one of three primary emotions. And it seemed like her goal was to make me cry every session. To be fair, she had a lot of potential. She did a lot of really important things and got me to look at lots of things differently. But she was young and very obviously inexperienced. But the worse thing about her was she was trying to juggle two kids and a career and she would flip flop between her priorities. She would frequently cancel or reschedule on such a basis that I didn't see her more than I saw her. She also didn't like that (after she read something in one of her books) I had another therapist, despite the fact that I was lucky if I saw her twice a month. The final straw came when I was suicidal and wouldn't drive and she tried to charge ME for canceling on her. She wanted it out of pocket, even though I was paying with Medi-Cal. Not only is that illegal, but she completely didn't understand what was going on. Instead of realizing that in trouble, she was mad I canceled. Once she understood, (after calling me and giving me a piece of her mind) she tried to be more sympathetic, but what was done was done. I had had enough. I do wish her the best though!
Takeaway: Flakes aren't worth dealing with no matter how great they are. You need REGULAR therapy for it to work. For me that means weekly, sometimes twice a week, for some people that means monthly. Find out a therapist that will work with and stick to your schedule.
The pessimist
This is my current therapist (who may be reading this for all I know. She's the only person with the link) who despite the name I have grown quite fond of.
She is unconventional and she is my current therapist, so I will speak with a degree of rose colored biased, since it is currently working. No therapist is without faults but I have found her to be (mostly) reliable, a good listener, and able to accommodate what I need. Twice a week? Sure, I got you. You want multiple therapists? Sure! You need me to be more optimistic? You got it. You need me to answer my texts more? Sure.
She is clear on what she can and cannot do. (No, do not expect me to get back to you ASAP, but I will get back to you. If it is an emergency, call a hotline, I am not trained in crisis). She is funny. She is supportive. She actually reads the things I send her and asks for them (writing wise). She sees more than she lets on. (Yes, you have GAD, yes, I know you're in a toxic relationship, but I'm not judging because I've been there). She respects my wishes (No, I will not hospitalize you unless we agree that's what's best for you). She helps me to come to my own conclusions (yes, you are really hard on yourself, why do you think that is?)
She is not always straightforward in what she sees and she is not always forthcoming with tools. She makes me find them myself, but since I'm stubborn enough that I tend to not take suggestions anyway, so it might just be me she's like that with. If there was one thing I would like to change about her, I think it would be that. I think a good therapist is forthcoming with that kind of thing. But I also respect that she makes me find my own answers and when I ask if we can do something, or if she has anything about xyz, she'll always give it to me. So that's her.
TAKEAWAY: The non judgmental person always wins. The adaptive person wins. I feel like she genuinely cares about and understands me, and we've been working together for a year now. I struggled with what to think about her at first, but now quite like her. There is a lot to be said for a longer therapeutic relationship. Someone knowing your history is indispensable, provided it's the right person. Your therapist should fight to help you. But they should also let you lead. You also need to realize that at different phases you may need different people. For where I am now, she is a good match. But if I was where I was when I first became ill, would she still be the best, given that she is not good in emergencies? I am not sure. Be aware of what you need and make sure your therapist is meeting all those points.
So, what does a standard session look like? It depends, that's why I wanted to show you all these examples of therapists who were both good and bad matches (mind, I didn't say bad therapists! They were all good in their own way, but they weren't always good for me!). A good therapist should: Meet your needs, listen, offer tools, and make you feel safe and unjudged.
A sample session will look like you sitting on a chair -- sometimes a couch, but not a weird one like in the cartoons -- and facing the therapist. They'll ask you what brought you in. And then you'll talk. Depending on what you mention will take the conversation different places. You may talk about what you want for the future, you may talk about the strained relationship with your dad, you may talk about your hobbies, your eating habits, your moods, your fears. The therapist may use tools -- puppets, dogs, body movements, breathing exercises, puzzles, paints, sand trays, -- or may just listen and ask questions. You may get homework. You may not.
You do not have to tell anyone that you are in therapy or what happened unless you want to. Many people may ask. It's your choice. Sometimes you may get into fears so deep, you're not going to tell anyone ever. Sometimes, you may just talk about how great (or terrible) your boss is and what you want to do that weekend.
But I do want to tell you this. Therapy is not scary. It is just you talking with a friend* who happens to be really good at what they do. With someone who cares and is knowledgeable. That's it. Therapy is all about looking at your mind and patterns and finding ways to better deal with the problems in your life.
*I use friend here to mean someone who cares and is kind and compassionate. A therapist should never use you as a support or act in a casual way.
So that's all for now folks. Hope this was helpful.
~ Emery